Red, A Crayon’s Story (and book give-away winner announced!)



RED, A Crayon’s Story by Michael Hall is wonderfully witty and clever and I’m excited to point out some of  the smart choices that this author/illustrator has made. First, notice the cover (above), the crayon’s wrapper is red, but its color is not. Uh oh.. here-in lies the problem.


The red crayon tries to draw red things, but no matter what, they come out wrong. They come out blue.


When the other crayon’s talk their dialogue stays very ‘crayon-like’,

“Right! He’s got to press harder.”,

“Really apply himself!”.

One of my favorite details is the red crayon’s grandparents. One is “Silver”, the other is “Gray”. They are little stubs of crayon with the name on their label barely showing— they are old and well worn! The illustrations, like the story, appear simple and straightforward. But there are a lot of nuances and layers to them. The crayons’ tops are all different shapes and their labels torn in various ways.

At one point, all the art supplies try to help the red crayon. In many picture books the cast doesn’t take this helpful stance, but instead teases, or makes the main character feel even worse. In Michael Hall’s story the narrator (who is the pencil) says,

“But even with all our help and all his hard work, he just couldn’t get the hang of it.”

In the end, the Berry crayon asks the red crayon (who now sports a snipped label because scissors thought his label might be too tight, and a band of masking tape which was added to help hold him together— the tape was worried that he might be broken inside) to draw a blue ocean for her boat. When it works, the “Red” crayon and all the others realize that he has found his true calling and can finally be himself.

This is a color book—- talking about mixing colors, and at the same time, it’s a book about feelings— trying to fit in and be something that you’re not. And because the other crayons are very supportive, it’s also a book about friendship and a caring community. I think when a picture book can be so deceptively simple, yet have so many layers, it’s elevated itself to above average.

Kids will love the funny crayon personalties and relate to the red crayon trying to find his true color, and they’ll learn a bit about color mixing to boot!


Jill’s book give away winner is—- doot, da, doooooooo—– Stephanie Lowden! Congrats, Stephanie, please contact Jill through her website at



Thank you!

Jennifer Black Reinhardt

Jennifer is the illustrator and author of several acclaimed picture books. Most recently is Always by My Side, 'A Stuffie Story', which she wrote and illustrated. She also is both the author and illustrator of Playing Possum, and Blue Ethel. Jennifer illustrated Gondra’s Treasure, written by Newbery award winner Linda Sue Park. As well as, Sometimes You Fly, by Newbery medalist, Katherine Applegate. She illustrated Yaks Yak, Animal Word Pairs by Linda Sue Park, The Inventor's Secret, What Thomas Edison Told Henry Ford, by Suzanne Slade, Rabbi Benjamin's Buttons, by Alice B. McGinty, and The Adventures of a South Pole Pig, by Chris Kurtz.


  1. This is a delightful story. I love the layering and support!


  2. Great fun read for children and parents. I loved the quiet ‘messages’ about labels don’t matter it’s what’s inside that counts, and about expectations and trying to fit in. All while telling a story with fun crayon characters = very relatable to children.

    Thanks for posting about it. I read it as soon as I arrived at the library today .


  3. I have to get my hands on this. Congratulations to Stephanie .

  4. Such a great book! I shared it with a preschool group (2 to 5 year olds) – each age getting something different from the story. Thanks for highlighting it here. =)

  5. Oh, how precious! Thanks for sharing this book with us!

  6. Wonderful story. I don’t think I caught the short gray and silver the first 5 times I read it! I go back and look.

  7. That book sounds wonderful~I’d love to read it to my 1st graders!

  8. So much cleverness in this book that I had to take it home with me. My favorite thing is how every crayon has its own distinct personality.

  9. I read this story with my kids last week. So much to admire here! It’s a simple story–yet the message is deep, and the illustrations are thought-provoking and nuanced. And the message of being true to oneself could be applied in many situations, to help kids relate to many kinds of “different”.

  10. Heather, I’m so happy that you and your kids enjoyed this book. Thank you so much for visiting our blog and posting your comment!

  11. Heather Elizabeth

    Super cute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *