How and Why Katherine Applegate and I made SOMETIMES YOU FLY + GiVeAwAY!

Some of you may have heard of the author of the recent book I illustrated? Her name is Katherine Applegate. And, friends, this talented Newbery Medalist is as thoughtful and lovely as the books she writes. What an honor and privilege it has been to be a part of Sometimes You Fly, which released from HMH, Clarion on April 3.

Katherine has answered a few questions and will tell us about writing this special picture book.

Katherine, Where did the idea come from for sometimes you fly?

When I do school visits, I’m always struck by how often teachers ask me to tell students that rewriting is part of the writing process. Kids often think they have to do perfect work right from the start. They don’t realize that rewriting IS writing, and that making mistakes is an integral part of learning.

I wrote Sometimes You Fly to remind readers that before any major accomplishment come lots of false starts and stumbles. I wanted to celebrate all those highs and the lows we face when growing up. (And while being a grown-up!)

Did you always envision the book in the format that is now, with the before and after pages?

From the start, I had the refrain “Before the cake…” in my head. I’m a lousy cook, so the image of a messy, chaotic kitchen—the “before”—was easy to envision! Naturally, the “before” required an “after,” and that’s how the manuscript started.

I knew the real work of this book would lie with the illustrator, who would have to make the “before and after” concept work:  it’s a book that’s very reliant on the page turn. When I first saw Jennifer’s early sketches, I got tears in my eyes. It was such a joy to see her take a handful of words and turn them into beautifully realized scenes, full of comedy and tenderness and poignancy. It was pure magic.

What do you hope readers take away from this book?

I hope readers remember that it’s ok to fail. More than that — it’s necessary to fail! Failure and heartbreak lead to growth. They’re part of being human.

Sometimes we focus so much on milestones that we forget the most important part: the learning that goes into making a big moment happen. It’s important to celebrate that hard work, along with all the love and support from family and friends that made it possible. Life is messy, and full of ups and downs. It’s also magical.

The structure and layout of Sometimes You Fly was my biggest challenge as the illustrator. Katherine’s beautiful story is written in sparse prose and celebrates the ups and downs of life’s milestone accomplishments.

Each sentence in the beginning of the book starts with the words “before the…” something. The page turn is very, very important in the structure of Sometimes You Fly. My job as the illustrator was to tell the whole story of that character’s journey in one page turn. It needs to be very clear on the before page what particular challenge that character is struggling with, and then equally clear what their achievement is on the ‘after’ page.

Mostly by trial and error I stumbled into the layout device of having a vignette (which is a borderless illustration) on the ‘before’ page and a bordered full page illustration on the following page which showed the ‘after’.

For many months I offered up borders and colors to connect the two pages and carry through the page turn. Which in the end, we decided it didn’t need to have any borders at all.

Just as Katherine persisted through many written edits for the book, I worked to express the emotion and the actions of the images as clearly and concisely as possible. Here are a few versions of one little guy below. There were actually several more…

The original title of the book was, “Before the Cake”.

It’s not uncommon at all for the title of a book to change along the way, but it’s not so common to have it change it in the 11th hour of production. I was literally finishing my very last piece of artwork (not the last page of the book as I intentionally don’t work in order) I was told that the title had changed and would now be Sometimes You Fly, a change that I was actually very happy to hear. I had done many jacket sketches and none of us ever felt that any were right.

Katherine’s original wording, and the title, referred to the fact that the important things in life happen ‘before the cake’, before the reward. But, as a visual it was almost impossible not to think ‘cookbook’, ‘baking’, or ‘pastry’, and the imagery just didn’t represent the big, beautiful idea of the real meaning of the book.

Here are some examples of early jacket designs:

The title changing to “Sometimes You Fly” was much clearer as to what the book was about and brought to mind much lovelier imagery as well.

My favorite piece from the book? This poignant funeral scene. I think these are my favorite words in the book and the impact of everything not being easy in life is such a wonderful lesson to pass on.

“When breezes blow we learn to bend.”

You can watch the book trailer, here…

I hope that you like Sometimes You Fly!

To celebrate our book’s release please comment below and I’ll pick a name and send you a copy of the book as well as a beautiful art print from the publisher.
I’ll announce the winner next month when it’s my turn again (May 15)!


Thank you for visiting!

Jennifer Black Reinhardt

Jennifer is the illustrator and author of several acclaimed picture books. Most recently is Always by My Side, 'A Stuffie Story', which she wrote and illustrated. She also is both the author and illustrator of Playing Possum, and Blue Ethel. Jennifer illustrated Gondra’s Treasure, written by Newbery award winner Linda Sue Park. As well as, Sometimes You Fly, by Newbery medalist, Katherine Applegate. She illustrated Yaks Yak, Animal Word Pairs by Linda Sue Park, The Inventor's Secret, What Thomas Edison Told Henry Ford, by Suzanne Slade, Rabbi Benjamin's Buttons, by Alice B. McGinty, and The Adventures of a South Pole Pig, by Chris Kurtz.


  1. This is beautiful. I look forward to meeting the book in person!

  2. Thanks so much for this post. Reading about Sometimes You Fly, is such a wonderful way to start the day!

  3. I can’t wait to get this book in my hands! The illustrations are beautiful! Thanks for sharing your process.

  4. I think I will end up buying multiple copies of this book, it looks beautiful. Congratulations!

  5. Kim Pfennigwerth

    As a grandmother with one grandchild questioning where he fits – I can’t wait to get this book!

  6. Katherine’s words are beautiful and they absolutely come to life through your pictures, Jennifer! Can’t wait to read this book!

  7. This is sure to be a classic! The words and pictures work beautifully together. Congratulations Jennifer.

  8. Can’t wait to read it. Love the premise!

  9. Have heard many amazing things about this book! Thanks for the chance to win it!

  10. Oh, Jennifer. I love this–the book’s concept, your gorgeous art, and this behind-the-scenes post. Congratulations–this looks like a true gem. And, speaking of gems, I got to meet Katherine when she spoke at our library in Chapel Hill a few years ago. What a fabulous pairing! 🙂

  11. Oh wow, what an amazing book. Thanks for the behind-the-scenes look at things from both perspectives, and at different stages. Fascinating!
    I can’t wait to read this. Sounds like one that I’ll want to pore over again and again.

  12. Oh wow, this looks wonderful. I can already tell that I will have to add this to my shelf! Congratulations to you both and thanks for the sneak peak! It looks beautiful. (PS. I love Blue Ethel!!)

  13. This sounds, and looks, like an absolutely incredible book. I can’t wait to read it.

  14. What a beautiful book, Jennifer! Congratulations!

  15. Beautiful book! Love the text and the illustrations! Congratulations!

  16. Jennifer Rumberger

    Wow, your illustrations are beautiful for this book! Congratulations!

  17. This looks like a book that will be a perfect gift for lots of occasions from births to college graduation. It sounds and looks beautiful.

  18. This looks beautiful! I’ve just reserved a copy at my library.

  19. Wow, I love this so much and I haven’t even read the book yet! Can’t wait for this. Congratulations, Katherine and Jennifer!

    • Thanks, Katrina, I hope you like it! Thank you so much for the congrats. This book is very near and dear to my heart for many reasons.

      • This book is one of my new favorites. I have shared it again and again with my kids and I can’t wait to gift it to many more kids to come! It’s very special 🙂

        I’m curious, at what stage did you decide to show multiple narratives through the art instead of one continuous one (except for the beginning family…and I love that it ends with them, too!)? And why?

        • Hi Katrina! I’m so happy that you like our book and also a big THANK YOU for the shout outs on Twitter! That’s a great question. At first, I thought it should be one family. But when I thought about how everyone would have to age and wondered if that be always visually clear? When I mentioned that to my editor she said, “I thought they were all different children!” So, that’s the direction we went in. I liked having the bookended family as well as the kids on the cover and the case re-appearing at the very end to show how they apply what they have learned and are persistent. Again, thanks so much, Katrina!

  20. Debra K Shumaker

    Can’t wait to read this book! Looks just so lovely.

  21. Linda C Carpenter

    This looks so inspiring! I can’t wait to receive. Love the illustrations. A great post and perfect inspiration to start the day! Many thanks!

  22. Lynn Bartenhagen

    I love Jennifer’s illustrations and the book preview seems wonderful. Can’t wait to read it to my nieces and nephews.

  23. Love, love, love this so much!!!!

  24. I love this concept and the reminder to all that failure is just one more step toward success. I bet this book will fly! off shelves.

  25. Danielle Hammelef

    I enjoyed this interview and loved seeing the perspective of developing a picture book from both author and illustrator. I’m still trying to figure out how much text to include in my manuscript and what to leave out. The trailer is fantastic. I can’t wait to read this book for myself as the message applies to all ages.

    • Thank you so much for visiting and commenting, Danielle! Tomie DePaola says something to the effect that a well-written manuscript is one that leaves space for the illustrator to tell their part of the story. And remember that what you are struggling with, re: too much or not enough text, is exactly why editors are so amazing! Good luck with your ms!

  26. Carol Coven Grannick

    A wonderful story about what looks like a wonderful book. Gorgeous illustrations (congratulations!). And I have been a fan of Katherine’s from the beginning, and look forward to another exquisite book.

  27. This was really fun to read about how the title changed and the challenges the illustrator had to overcome. Looking forward to seeing the “after” product!

    • Hi Kathy! I like to point out the changes that go on in book making because they’re such a normal part of (as my agent says) ‘that book’s journey’. It’s ironic that that exact message is what this book itself is about! Hope you enjoy it!

  28. Lovely review of what looks to be a beautiful book! Can’t wait to read it.

  29. Wow, this books looks wonderful. I bet it’ll “fly” off the shelves! Congrats on another success!

  30. The melody of text and illustration sings so beautifully here. I can only imagine how the complete book must soar. Congratulations!

  31. I loved hearing you share at Prairie Lights on Sunday, Jennifer! This is a lovely book on so many levels. Congratulations to you & Katherine Applegate.

  32. You are such a wonderful and supportive friend. Thank you, it was terrific to see your lovely smile! And I am so happy that you like the book. That means a great deal to me!!!!

  33. Reading this post and watching the trailer I thought of a quote by Tennyson; The shell must break before the bird can fly…” Thank you for the inspiration.

  34. This book sounds delicious. Thanks for sharing, I have it on order!

  35. This looks fabulous! I can’t wait to read it. Congratulations, Jennifer and Katherine!

  36. What a great book you both created! I love seeing how the author and illustrator work and rework their contributions that make an outstanding picture book. Thank you, Jennifer and Katherine. I look forward to reading it!

  37. This looks A-MAZING! Congrats and thanks for the sneak peek into the creation process.

  38. Loved reading about the careful, beautiful collaboration that took it’s own sweet time. Perfection never comes easily. It made me think of ALBERT by Donna Jo Napoli and Jim LaMarche.

    • “it’s own sweet time”, exactly Karen! I’m not sure I believe in perfection, especially when something as subjective as art is involved, but I think if we can create a picture book that people can relate to, connect with, and enjoy, I will feel successful. Thank you so much!!!!

  39. OMG — just love everything about this book. Best of luck to you both!

  40. Jennifer, I am so pleased to have found your blog. What a beautiful project and such a great message for children and adults alike! I really enjoyed reading about the process and am looking forward to getting my hands on a copy of this inspirational book.

    • Hi, Colee and welcome! I’m so glad you found our blog and that you’re excited to read Sometimes You Fly. It was really fun to work on a book that is written to be a picture book for all ages. I believe that picture book making is an art form and not just meant for children. It was extra-exciting to work on this project because of that!

  41. I love Katherine Applegate’s writing so I know I’ll just love this book too!

  42. Oh, my! What a gorgeous book!

  43. What a great message to share with kids. Can’t wait to read this beautiful book. Thanks for sharing!

  44. This is a must have book!

  45. I love this book already – the words and pictures work so well together, and the important message is presented in such a beautiful way. I have a feeling this may become my favorite book!

  46. This gives me goosebumps! I just love your illustration style, Jennifer! What a wonderful bird’s-eye view you’ve given us. May the book take flight to great heights.

  47. Wow, this looks really powerful. And whimsical at the same time. I can’t wait to see it in person.

  48. LOVE your art, Jennifer, and I LOVE Katherine Applegate’s writing. The One & Only Ivan is truly one of my most very favorite books (I am a fan of Bob the dog 😉 ). I cannot wait to read this–congrats to you both!!

    I would love an art print and a copy of the book–fingers crossed :)!!

  49. I teach Kindergarten and I think that this is a perfect story to share with Kindergarten graduation. Thank you for sharing

  50. This is a must have! The words and illustrations are beautiful together. Looking forward to reading it.

  51. What a wonderful book! I like hearing about both your processes of making the book. The use of the vignette before the page turn and the bordered art after the page turn is so clever, Jennifer – moves the reader from unfinished to finished. Congratulations on a lovely book!

  52. Gorgeous. This seems like a heartfelt, moving book. Jennifer, I’m a big fan of your work. Love your quirky characters, fanciful settings, thoughtful layouts, and ephemeral touch when it comes to elements like wind/smoke/sky/clouds.

  53. This looks stunning! I can’t wait to get a copy.
    Thanks for the peek into the crafting of a beautiful book.

  54. Beautiful! Looking forward to reading it!

  55. This looks beautiful – both words and art.

  56. Stacy Digianantonio

    I love anything and everything by Katherine Applegate! The illustrations are very charming . . . I can’t wait to read this!

  57. BEAUTIFUL illustrations!
    BEAUTIFUL rhyme!

    Thank you Jennifer for sharing this book!!

  58. What a beautiful message – one I needed today! Thank you, the struggle is real – today was not my day to fly, but I’ll keep my eye to the skies ?☀️.

  59. Lindsay Hanson Metcalf

    Oh, my goodness, this looks like a perfect picture book. Congratulations to you both.

  60. Kathy Mazurowski

    Wow! This is the number one book on my to get list! The trailer did it forme. Thank you!

  61. love process, love process, love process — these types of post are so wonderful!

  62. This books looks incredible! Congrats!

  63. picturebookbuilders

    What a beautiful book! A must-have!

  64. I absolutely love the premise and this post about how you carried it out! Super! Maybe it’s because I just wrote a post about my revision process for my debut PB. Soooooo much happens before the “cake.” And the collaboration is so interesting. Thanks! Ordering pronto!

  65. What a wonderful and beautiful looking book! You’ve already made this a book that I can’t imagine anyone else illustrating but you. Can’t wait to see this one in person.

  66. Wow, Mike, the illustrator knows the nicest thing he could say to an illustrator! Thank for that very kind compliment! Hope you like it when you see it. And thank you again!

  67. I love how your illustrations match the quiet, poignant feel of the story. I can’t wait to add it to y shelves! Congratulations!

  68. This looks absolutely beautiful – both the illustrations and text, as well as the important message, which is just as important for adults as kids! Congratulations on this inspiring creation and thank you for the sneak peek!

  69. I can’t wait to have this book in my hands. Gorgeous illustrations to go with beautiful, poignant words. A perfect pairing. Congratulations Katherine and Jennifer!!!

  70. I love books that teach us as well as our readers. This is an important lesson. Thank you!

  71. Thank you for sharing! I had not heard of this book. Sounds beautiful. Can’t wait to read it.

  72. I cannot wait to read this beautiful book. Thank you for sharing the journey…before the publishing. Inspired!

  73. I cannot wait to read this beautiful book. Inspired to Read the journey…before the publishing.

  74. my dream book!

  75. Wow! Loved hearing about the process–especially that 11th hour title change. Good grief!

  76. This looks so good. Looking forward to seeing how the page turns work. Love the title!

  77. Lovely article about a lovely book! I I enjoyed seeing how the illustrations worked and ended up adding so much to the book. Thanks!

  78. The artwork for this book is beautiful. Thank you for the inside scoop on how a book comes together. To me it seems like magic.

    • Hi Heather, truly it ‘seems like magic’ to me, too. To be working with people who love books as much as I do, and to get to be a part of that process will always be an amazing blessing that I will never take for granted. Thanks for your comment and for visiting PBB!

  79. Wow, both of you really tapped into something so necessary… I am trying to teach my son this exact lesson…and your lovely book seems to do it in a poignant and accessible way that I am sure kids and adults will respond to.

    Congrats on your well deserved success!??

  80. Hi Susan, I am very, very proud to be part of a book with such a beautiful message. Thank you for your kind words!

  81. Love the text and the art! Thanks for the inspiration to keep trying to fly. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *